Thanks for visiting! This blog will give you tips you can use to raise more money with your communications.


Showing posts with label reciprocity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reciprocity. Show all posts

October 29, 2014

This is from a cute comic titled "9 Ways to Get People To Do What You Want:"
http://thesecretyumiverse.wonderhowto.com/how-to/9-ways-get-people-do-what-you-want-0135125/

You can click to see the whole comic. So, what from this list applies to fundraising communications work?
  • "Be charming, confident and likeable." Which organization would you rather support, the one who says "with your help, we will solve x problem," or one that says "we might be able to solve x, we'll try..." As for charming and likeable, how about that potato salad kickstarter?

  • "At the beginning of the conversation, make the person say 'yes.'" A great example of this is petition-signing. She has already proven herself to care about the issue enough to sign the petition; now it's less of a stretch for her to donate to support it.

  • "Make the person feel respected and important." Hello, donor-centeredness!

  • "Push for a feeling, rather than something tangible." We know that most donation decisions are influenced by emotions, not logic.

  • "Tap into the person's imagination." You see this a lot in fundraising messaging. "Can you imagine going to school hungry? Jimmy does..." "Imagine, Pawnee's river completely cleaned up by 2016!" Reaching people's imaginations helps make your messaging compelling.

  • "Do a big favor for the other person so he or she feels obligated to do something for you." Again, you see this a lot with charities that send out mailing labels, notepads, etc., a practice that is getting increasingly controversial. (Here are more posts about using reciprocity in your communications.)

  • "Challenge a person to do something, as opposed to telling them to do something." Does this remind you of the wildly-successful Ice Bucket Challenge campaign?

  • "Claim that you have the person's best interests in mind." I've said it before (and I'll say it again, surely): people don't give to your organization, they give through your organization to make a difference. Make it clear that you want the same things. "With your help, we'll preserve the Pawnee Historical Museum, so you and your family can enjoy it for many years to come."

May 3, 2013

Are freebies a good way to get donations?

In an earlier post, I wrote about including free return address labels with solicitations, using the reciprocity principle to persuade individuals to donate.  I wondered if, rather than motivating people to give, it could possibly alienate them instead.

This Dear Abby column addresses this practice; it's actually a follow-up column because she got so much mail on the issue.  Says Abby: "Letters from readers complaining about charitable donation requests with labels arrive in my office on a daily basis..."

Some highlights:
"My view is, if they're using my donation to send gifts, then they really don't need my money.  They should be using donations to help whomever or whatever it is they're soliciting for."
"There's nothing 'free' when organizations try to guilt us into sending money.  My solution for all this junk is, use the labels and anything personalized if I like them; if not, destroy them." 
As a fundraiser, I find this woman's story pretty horrifying (italics mine):
"Last year, for about six months, I collected all the requests for donations I received.  Abby, the total was 532 requests from 119 organizations!...I no longer feel guilty about tossing them.  I sent all of them letters requesting they delete my name from their lists.  118 ignored my request...I give the notepads and other enclosures to Goodwill and shred the labels...I donate less than I ever have in the past because I feel so hounded, so in my case, it has worked against them."
One would think that organizations continue this practice because, well, it works.  But comments like these, from people who are sick and tired of it, give us something to think about.  You can read the Yahoo! comments below the column for even more. 

I want to know what you think—is including freebies with your solicitations a good idea?

February 13, 2013

Are your appeals the absolute best they can be?

I sure love checklists, because they're simple ways to make sure your communications will perform as well as possible.  (As seen earlier here on my blog.)  Do yourself a favor and check out this list of ideas from Showcase of Fundraising Innovation and Inspiration.  It's terrific!

I have a few things to say about it:


  • Note #7—reciprocity.  As SOFII say here, "use with care and prudence," so as not to cause "obligation to descend into resentment."  I say stick with this part of that idea: "Perhaps there are better things [than items] you can 'give'...such as special access, insider information – or even gratitude..."

  • I love the (non-mandatory, non-monetary) pledge for new donors to "‘continue [her] regular gift for as long as [she] can afford it'" in #8.

  • #12's idea about limiting the number of donors for a project with special benefits is incredible.  If you ask me, that's what the point of #7 is—talk about your special access!

  How can you apply these principles to your fundraising?

    February 10, 2013

    Some science behind persuasion

    Fundraising communications professionals aren't the only ones who want to influence people; so do business marketers, salespeople, politicians...the list goes on.  Thanks to the diversity of folks who want to sway others, there is a good amount of research devoted to the science of persuasion.  There is an article in Business Week about scientifically-proven principles for influencing others, which includes:

    • Liking: People like those...who like them.
      Or, be friends with your donors.  This is why fundraising letters should sound like a letter from a pal—a pal who really appreciates everything you've done for him, of course.

    • Reciprocity: People repay in kind.
      The Business Week article actually uses nonprofit fundraising in this example, the good old "free personalized address labels included" tactic.  I would be interested to see some more recent research about this technique, as I wonder if it is starting to turn donors off due to the market being saturated with it.  People may tire of getting items they didn't ask for, but the idea of reciprocity (you helped me, now I feel compelled to help you) in humans is timeless.

    • Social Proof: People follow the lead of similar others.
      Katya Andresen's blog has a great article about what happened when researchers put a clear donation box in the entrance to a gallery.
        You should read the article if you haven't, but in (very) short: people gave more when there was money in the box than when the box was empty.  Takeaway: people want to fit in, and most people don't want to be first.  So, if you have a sign-up sheet, sign a few people in at the top so that no one has to be first.  If you want to use a thermometer showing how far along you are in your goal, don't share that thermometer until you have received some money already.  If you are going to have a live auction, make sure you have someone in the audience who is willing to be the first to bid.

    • Authority: People defer to experts who provide shortcuts to decisions requiring specialized information.
      Good fundraising materials tug at the heartstrings, but donors have to trust that you know what you're talking about.  The best way for this to happen is for your organization to become a trusted authority on your subject(s)—think of the reputations of the ACLU or the World Wildlife Fund.  You can also quote other respected sources discussing your organization or the problem it aims to solve.

    January 5, 2013

    A great end-of-year fundraising letter

    Happy New Year, everyone!

    As fundraisers, the end of every year is always a busy time (especially if your fiscal year matches the calendar year), and I hope everyone has recovered so we can all make 2012 the best year yet!

    I want to share with you a fantastic end-of-year email appeal from the year before last. I have heard non-fundraisers discussing it, saying things like "I don't normally donate, but this email made me want to give," etc. It's from 350.org. It makes terrific use of multiple donate links, spacing, and text bolding, but I'm going to break down in detail what makes it so great.
    From: Bill McKibben - 350.org
    Subject: We hate doing this.
    We can begin with the "From" and "Subject" fields. First of all, it has the name of a human in the From field, you know, like an email from an actual person. Secondly, what a strange, intriguing subject line. Doesn't it just make you want to open it? 
    Dear friends,

    This email violates all our precepts here at 350.org -- it’s the time of year we do something we hate, which is asking for money.

    We hate it for two reasons:

    One: many of our supporters are in the poorest parts of the planet and have no money to contribute. Even in rich parts of the world it’s been a tough year. If you don’t have funds to spare, don’t even think about giving.
    This acknowledges the tough times that many people are facing in a way that is sensitive, but not a downer. The truth is you don't want to remind people too much about the current economic situation; it has a chance of deterring them from donating.
    Two: Far more than we want people giving money, we want people taking action. That’s our first, second, and third priority -- that’s what we ask for 9 times out of 10.
    But we’ve had so many people taking so many actions this year that this whole 350 project has grown like crazy. It’s completely great. And it means we need the resources to coordinate it all, to make it more than the sum of its parts.
    This portion emphasizes the organization's successes over the year. But if you ask me, it's a subtle reminder that maybe the donor didn't do, physically, as much as he or she could have. The reader might feel a bit bad about that. The reader might want to write a check to ease that feeling of guilt.
    So today, we’re asking you to donate to help the movement grow. Click here to chip in whatever you can.

    Our crew is small and frugal -- and we’ll make your donations go far. We’ve never had a busier year than 2011: we stopped a massive oil pipeline, ran activist trainings all over the world, had our third giant day of climate action, orchestrated a creative project to take over the airwaves, joined forces with the Occupy movements, and on and on and on.

    It truly was a banner year, and our crew has put together an amazing “Top 11 Moments of 2011” recap. Check it out here.
    Again, reminding supporters of the work that has been accomplished over the past year, but, more importantly, reassuring the reader that her money makes a difference and the organization's "small and frugal" crew will "make your donations go far."  
    Next year is going to be big. We’re going to try and take on the oil and coal and gas companies directly -- strip away their subsidies, and take away their political power. To do it we need not just your activism but, if you can swing it, your financial help. Most of us (me included) are volunteers, and the young people on the staff are paid too little. But they make up for it with big-hearted effort; if we can raise more money we can hire more of them, in every corner of the planet.
    This does a nice job of inspiring the reader with hope for what's to come in the following year, and reminds him of the hard work that the staff and volunteers put in. People respond to the hard work and sacrifice of others; this is why 5K runs, 3-day walks, marathons, etc. are successful fundraisers. (I mentioned this before in my post about what the Occupy movement can teach us about fundraising.)
    You’ve already helped this year -- helped take the passion and creativity of thousands and channel it into real, tangible progress on our climate trouble. If you can help a little more before year’s end -- well, we will put it to good use. Click here to make a donation.

    This year surprised me a lot. I didn’t think I’d spend some of it in jail, and I didn’t truly think we could slow down the Keystone Pipeline. But I’m mighty glad we did -- and I’m ready to be surprised again in 2012.
    Informing/reminding that the letter writer went to jail for the cause? Talk about sacrifice and dedication! It inspires this feeling: "If Bill can go to jail, I can write a check, can't I?" Especially because right before it he recognized the supporter: "You've already helped this year."
    So many thanks,
    Bill McKibben for 350.org
    Again, thanks and recognition. And it's a very genuine, very human sign-off. When in doubt, ask yourself: What would a person say? At the end of the day, the letter is from a person, to a person. That connection is what development is all about.